Nov. 8, 2012: Fannie & Freddie making some coin while Ginnie volumes are huge; lack of inventory to impact Realtor ranks?
Rob Chrisman
Yesterday
the commentary reported on the news that New Traditions
National Bank will become a subsidiary of Old Florida
Bancshares, prompting one punster to write, "Does that make it
'New Old Florida Bank' kinda like Fifth Third Bank? (Most in
the industry know that Fifth Third's name is the
result of the 1908 merger of Third National Bank and Fifth
National Bank, to become the Fifth Third National Bank of
Cincinnati. Per good ol' Wikipedia, "while Third National was
the senior partner, the merger took place during a period when
prohibitionist ideas were gaining popularity, and it is legend
that 'Fifth Third' was better than 'Third Fifth,' which could
have been construed as a reference to three 'fifths' of
alcohol." In 1969 it was changed to Fifth Third Bank. Use that
one at Happy Hour tonight!)
Not everything that counts can be counted and not
everything that can be counted counts. But the U.S.
Census Bureau has released its 2011 American Housing Survey,
which covers topics ranging from financing, inventory, and
vacancies to householder satisfaction, health hazards, and
sewage. The data is downloadable via the links on the AHS
page (http://www.census.gov/housing/ahs/).
As
home prices improve, analysts are now saying (albeit
cautiously) that prices bottomed in the first quarter of 2012
and should continue on a slow but steady upward trajectory
over the next four to five years. The general consensus is
that they’ll rise by 3-4% annually, a trend that, if it
continued, would put them back at 2006 prices by 2021.
Heck, I don’t even know where I am eating lunch today – how
can someone predict prices out that far? And did these
same people predict where we’d be now ten years ago?
For
the time being, however, there’s still a lot of inventory out
there in some markets, and hardly any in others. In fact, a
top LO from Northern California and wrote to me, “Given
the lack of inventory and sales, my bet is this business
cycle weeds out a lot of weak Realtors.” Inventory
obviously has a bearing on home prices. About 3.3 million
homes are seriously delinquent or in foreclosure, but, seeing
as foreclosed borrowers still live somewhere, it’s the total
excess supply that will affect the housing market, and excess
units number about 2.6 million at this point. Considering that
200,000-350,000 new homes make their way onto the market and
1.1 new households are formed annually, though, that excess
supply is on track to be cleared out in the next few years.
The FHFA’s REO program will also likely play a role in
clearing vacancies, especially in MSAs like Miami, Phoenix,
and Chicago, where rental yields are high and there’s a
sufficiently dense geographic concentration of REO
properties. By bringing government capital into the rental
space, the program could result in lower yields, along with
creating opportunities for economies of scale. However, the
program isn’t comprehensive enough to clear out the backlog of
inventory on its own, as only 10% of the entire REO inventory
held by the GSEs is being rented, and in many areas, the
yields on rental properties are too low to spark the interest
of private investors.
But
the agencies are there for us! At Freddie, Fannie, and to
some extent Ginnie, all those higher gfees, salary caps,
buybacks, renting economy rather than mid-size cars, etc.
are paying dividends. Well, dividends to the government
to be precise. Under the "an improving market covers up a lot
of ailments" category, a turnaround in housing is also helping
drive Freddie & Fannie to profitability, and giving them
the right to tell the press and politicians to get off their
proverbial back.
Freddie
Mac
had a $2.9 billion profit in the third quarter,
down slightly from the $3.0 billion Q2 number, but it helped
keep the company from making any additional Treasury draws.
And it is the 4th straight quarter of profits! In
addition, Freddie’s comprehensive income of $5.6 billion in Q3
allowed it to pay a $1.8 billion dividend on senior preferred
stock – the press needs to talk about that! Year-to-date,
Freddie Mac’s net income and comprehensive income totaled $6.5
billion and $10.3 billion, respectively, at the end of
September. The company’s net worth was $4.9 billion, up $3.8
billion from Q2. Freddie’s inventory of delinquent loans is at
the lowest level in two years. The single-family serious
delinquency rate is still around 3.4% but heading down, and
while the seriously delinquency rate is higher than it was in
years prior to 2009 it is significantly lower than the rate
for the entire U.S. mortgage market - 7.3% at June 30
according to the MBA’s National Delinquency Survey.
Over
at Fannie, it earned $1.8 billion from July through
September,
“helped by an improving housing market that has lifted home
prices,” and paid a dividend of $2.9 billion to the U.S.
Treasury and sought no additional federal aid. It was Fannie's
third profitable quarter since being taken over by the
government during the 2008 financial crisis. You and me, and a
few million other taxpayers, have spent about $116 billion to
rescue Fannie but they’re chipping away at paying us back: so
far, the company has repaid the government $23 billion. Under
a new federal policy announced last summer, Fannie and Freddie
have to turn over all profits they earn every quarter to the
government. The change was made to ensure that the companies
pay the government back. Something tells me we won’t be
seeing that money come back to the taxpayer…
And their sister Ginnie Mae announced that it guaranteed
over $39 billion in mortgage-backed securities (MBS) in
September. For the second consecutive month Ginnie Mae’s
issuance is very close to $40 billion. Issuance for Ginnie Mae
II single-family pools led the way with more than $31 billion,
while Ginnie Mae I single-family pools totaled about $6
billion. Issuance for Ginnie Mae Home Equity Conversion
Mortgage-Backed Securities (HMBS), included in Ginnie Mae II
single-family pools, came in at $600 million. Total
single-family issuance for September was $37.275 billion.
Ginnie Mae’s multifamily MBS issuance was more than $1.805
billion.
(As
a very quick primer, “Ginnie Mae raises capital from investors
in the global credit markets to ensure liquidity for
affordable rental and homeownership opportunities across the
country. Through its MBS, Ginnie Mae finances housing mortgage
programs run by the FHA, VA, the Office of Public and Indian
Housing, and the Department of Agriculture’s Rural Development
Housing and Community Facilities Program. It only has about 100
full time employees – always a surprise to those who
didn’t know that.)
On
to some other somewhat recent investor, and MI updates,
along with the usual disclaimer that it is best to read the
bulletin for full details, but this will give you a flavor for
current trends.
All
conventional loans locked, re-locked or extended with Affiliated
Mortgage on or after October 29th will be subject to
overlays additional to those set out by DU 9.0. Conforming
fixed-rate, LIBOR ARM, and high balance fixed-rate loans for
2-4 unit primary residences will require six months’ reserves,
and the maximum LTV/CLTV/HCLTV for conforming LIBOR ARMs has
been updated. All conforming high balance fixed-rate products
will also be subject to a minimum credit score requirement of
680. And AMC has updated its Settlement Agent List, which can
be viewed in full at http://www.affiliatedcorrespondent.com/wc/content/exhibits/5-01_Settlement_Agent_list.pdf.
MGIC is consolidating its two monthly premium plans
such that all monthly requests will be processed as ZOMP
Monthlies, with no premium required at closing. This does not
apply to HARP loans; existing Standard Monthlies for HARP
Refi-to-Mod transactions will not be converted to ZOMPs.
MSI is requiring that, for all refinance borrowers
formerly involved in bankruptcy proceedings, sellers must
verify that the loan being refinanced was not a debt included
in the insolvency proceeding and that the subject property was
reaffirmed when bankruptcy papers were filed. Credit reports
will not be accepted as confirmation of reaffirmed debts.
This applies to all loans with immediate effect.
Due to the difficulties associated with assigning jumbo loans
after close with DU, MSI is requiring that all jumbo loans be
submitted to LP.
As per the Flood Insurance Modernization Act, MSI has
clarified that the minimum policy must compensate for any
damage or loss on a replacement basis, which must be at least
the amount noted on the hazard insurance policy.
SunWest has updated guidance on a number of topics,
including manufactured housing; income stability, validation
and verification; non-occupying co-borrower restrictions;
refinanced mortgages that are included in bankruptcies;
appraisal requirements; Power of Attorney and Revocable
Trusts; credit reports, credit supplements; and undisclosed
debt requirements; strategic foreclosures; and Streamline
refinance eligibility restrictions on previously modified
mortgages and unemployed borrowers. To view the changes in
full, see http://trk.cpro30.com/Tracking/t.c?WUJe-csqo-1CDIpl0.
Edging into the usual market commentary below, I wanted to
pass this along first. Tad Dahlke from Banc of Manhattan
notes, "The combination of rising dollar prices and weakness
in TBA dollar rolls has translated into steady strength in
payups. Over the last week we've seen balance pool 30-year
3.5s move another notch higher. 30-year 3.0’s are gradually
developing a more established market in several categories,
while 4.0s remain exceptionally well-bid due to REIT and CMO
demand." Sure enough, when one looks at the increase in prices
for pools made up of low loan amount loans ($175k or less),
refi's above 80%, low FICO, investor, or New York loans, one
sees higher prices by as much as 1.5 points (so-called “specified
pools”). Of course, mortgage banks, either unable to
securitize loans, or those without enough production to form
securities, sell suitable loans to the aggregators or to the
agencies, and they're the ones who benefit from the price
difference. It is a profit motivated world out there!
And
looking at the markets, equity markets dominated the news
Wednesday with stocks suffering their largest one-day hit in
2012. (We’re seeing a bit of a bounce today.) But LO’s are
cheering current events (unless they locked their pipelines
Monday & Tuesday) as 30-year FNMA 2.5% and 3.0% coupons
surged “higher and tighter” as investors perceived that QE3
will be alive and well for many months, perhaps years. But
investor owning higher coupon MBS got smacked as prices
actually dropped: they received a double whammy between
President Obama's re-election (FHFA Director DeMarco’s days
are numbered, and his replacement will want to increase
refinancing credit-impaired borrowers who have higher rates),
and much faster than expected prepayments in October.
Tradeweb
MBS volume came in 122% of its 30-day moving average, but the
volumes didn’t dampen prices much: prices on 30-year FNMA 3.0s
improved about .625 and over .75 on 30-yr 2.5’s. How much
of that makes it on to rate sheets remains to be seen!
Our risk free 10-yr T-note closed at 1.63%.
But
that was yesterday. Today we’ve had Initial Claims (expected
to go from 363k to 370k, but actually moved lower to 355k) and
continuing jobless claims that also dropped. We also had the
International Trade numbers that actually showed a smaller
deficit than expected (-$41.5 billion). And later we’ll have
the final leg of the Treasury refunding with $16 billion in
30-year bonds auctioned at 1PM EST. The 10-yr is currently
at 1.68% and MBS prices are worse about .125.
The Borowitz Reports observed:
One day after the costliest Presidential election in U.S.
history, Americans awoke to the ugly realization that the
nation had spent $2.5 billion with absolutely nothing to show
for it.
“Four
years ago, Barack Obama was elected President of the United
States, and that is still the case,” says Professor Davis
Logsdon of the University of Minnesota. “The only difference
is that we as a nation are out $2.5 billion.”
Mr. Logsdon claims that America’s system of egregious
political spending “has made us the laughingstock of the
world,” arguing, “Even Greece would know better than to blow
through money like that.”
But “not so fast,” says Tracy Klugian, President of the
Negative Advertising Association of America, which represents
the nation’s leading producers of political attack ads.
“When people complain about how expensive these political
campaigns are, they’re forgetting about the millions of
Americans who are employed making negative ads,” he says. “Say
what you will about lies, vitriol and character assassination,
they’re job creators.”
In fact, Mr. Klugian says, America’s costly and interminable
campaigns are the nation’s most reliable source of employment:
“They gave a completely unskilled person like Mitt Romney a
steady job for eight years.”
Acknowledging that the $2.5 billion spent this year was a
“tidy sum,” Mr. Klugian says, “If we took all the money we
spend on political ads and used it to educate our children and
feed the poor, we wouldn’t be America.”
If
you're interested, visit my twice-a-month blog at the STRATMOR
Group web site located at www.stratmorgroup.com.
The current blog discusses some of the considerations facing
the FHFA regarding Fannie and Freddie. If you have both the
time and inclination, make a comment on what I have written,
or on other comments so that folks can learn what's going on
out there from the other readers.