Jul. 2, 2012: Profit per loan up dramatically - mortgage banks focused on purchase biz; LO's not exempt from OT?
Rob Chrisman
On
July 4th in 1776, the Declaration of Independence was approved
by the Continental Congress, setting the 13 colonies on the road
to freedom as a sovereign nation. (This year it has turned
tomorrow into somewhat of a “get away” day for many.) As always,
parades, fireworks and backyard barbecues await. It is estimated
by the Census that there were 2.5 million people living in
the nation at that point, and now there are 314 million:http://www.census.gov/main/www/popclock.html.
Check
this out, for some non-mortgage news: Reuters reports that
Chinese auto stocks fell steeply Mon after Guangzhou became the
country’s 4th major city to place a cap on annual
auto sales. Guangzhou is looking to ease traffic
congestion. Supply and demand suggest that prices will go up, or
a black market will spring up.
The MBA puts out some pretty good statistics, and this
last set showed that independent mortgage banks and mortgage
subsidiaries of chartered banks made an average profit of
$1,654 on each loan they originated in the first quarter,
up from $1,093 per loan in the fourth quarter. The MBA Quarterly
Mortgage Bankers Performance Report said while per-loan
production expenses increased, secondary marketing gains
improved as primary-secondary spreads widened. Secondary
marketing income rose from $4,355 per loan in the fourth
quarter to $5,011 per loan in the first quarter. “For
independent mortgage bankers, average production volume and the
purchase share of that volume remained relatively constant in
the first quarter, compared to the previous quarter,” said MBA
Associate Vice President of Industry Analysis Marina Walsh. “Independent
mortgage bankers remained focused on purchase production while
many larger banking institutions were handling significantly
more refinancing activity.” To buy the report: http://www.mbaa.org/ResearchandForecasts/.
My crack team of research analysts (Myrtle the cat and Sweetie
the dog) sometimes doesn’t get around to all the news. But this
one caught their eye - a story in the Wall Street Journal: "Bank
of America Corp. thought it had a bargain four years ago
when it paid $2.5 billion for tottering mortgage lender Countrywide
Financial Corp. But the ill-fated decision has already
cost BofA more than $40 billion in real-estate losses, legal
expenses and settlements with state and federal agencies,
according to people close to the bank. 'It is the worst deal
in the history of American finance,' said Tony Plath, a
banking and finance professor at the University of North
Carolina at Charlotte. 'Hands down.'"
Sales of homes that were in some stage of foreclosure, real
estate-owned (REO), or bank-owned accounted for 26% of all
U.S. residential sales during the first quarter—up from
22% of all sales in the fourth quarter and up from 25% of all
sales in the first quarter of 2011. Foreclosure-related sales
picked up in the first quarter, particularly pre-foreclosure
sales where a distressed homeowner is selling to avoid
foreclosure—typically via short sale. Those pre-foreclosure
sales hit a three-year high in the first quarter even as the
average pre-foreclosure sales price dropped to a record low as
lenders are approving more aggressively priced short sales. California
foreclosure-related sales accounted for 47% of the state’s
total residential property sales in the first quarter, the
second-highest percentage among the states. Foreclosure sales
accounted for 46 percent of all residential sales in Georgia
during the first quarter, the third highest percentage of any
state.
Not that I want to be the sounding board for various
underwriting scenarios or guideline suggestions, but here's an
interesting note that I received. "I am located in Texas. We are
in the middle of a state that can produce a lot of borrowers
with oil & gas income on their tax returns. In most cases
this is the only source of income and has been for years. Fannie
Mae guidelines as well as most lenders’ guidelines state that in
order to use this income for qualification the borrower must
show “proof of continuance for 3 years”. Anyone that truly
understands the oil & gas business sees this statement as
ludicrous at best. The proof most often requested from
processors and underwriters is 'a copy of the oil & gas
lease showing at least 3 years remaining'. I have one borrower I
had to turn down who has over 7,000 fractional interests in
minerals and royalties generating over $500K a year and has been
for years but has no lease nor an engineer’s study (way too
expensive to produce) to prove continuance due to reserves.
Fannie Mae and all lenders need to put on their thinking caps
and figure this out. This is becoming a major problem in our
neck of the woods."
K&L
Gates reports that a federal district judge in Washington, D.C.
has upheld an “Administrator’s Interpretation” issued in 2010 by
the U.S. Department of Labor (“DOL”) that loan officers in
the mortgage banking industry typically do not qualify as
exempt employees under the administrative exemption of the
federal Fair Labor Standards Act (“FLSA”). The Mortgage Bankers
Association (“MBA”) had challenged the March 24, 2010
Administrator’s Interpretation (“Interpretation”) issued by the
Acting Administrator of DOL’s Wage and Hour Division because the
Interpretation had reversed and rescinded a contrary DOL Opinion
Letter issued in 2006 that had concluded mortgage loan officers
were generally exempt under the administrative exemption.
However, a judge ruled that the 2010 Interpretation was not
inconsistent with the FLSA regulations and was not arbitrary,
capricious, or otherwise unlawful. [1] The court thus let stand
the DOL’s Interpretation that employees performing the typical
duties of a mortgage loan officer do not qualify for the
administrative exemption and are therefore entitled to receive
minimum wages and overtime compensation under the protections of
the FLSA. [2] The MBA has the right to appeal this decision to
the D.C. Circuit. http://www.klgates.com/court-upholds-labor-department-interpretation-that-mortgage-loan-officers-are-not-exempt-from-overtime-06-19-2012/
Counterparty risk is certainly increasing in scope. The
Financial Stability Board (FSB) recently released its Principles
for Sound Residential Mortgage Underwriting Practices. FSB, an
international body established after the 2009 G-20 Summit to
oversee and recommend on the global financial system includes
representatives of all G-20 economies. The recommendations the
board most recently issued are meant to address problems arising
from poorly underwritten residential mortgages. The board
stressed how weak underwriting practices in only one country
can contribute significantly to the global financial crisis,
and the importance of having sound underwriting practices at the
point at which a mortgage loan is originally made. The
principles cover several areas which proved to be particularly
weak during the global financial crisis. Among them are
effective verification of income and other financial
information, reasonable debt service coverage, appropriate
loan-to-value ratios, effective collateral management, and
prudent use of mortgage insurance.
Here
are some somewhat recent investor/M&A/agency/MERS updates,
providing a flavor for the environment. They just don’t stop. As
always, it is best to read the actual bulletin.
Fannie Mae Updated its Data Breach Policy, Compensatory
Fees, and Allowable Foreclosure Timeframes. On June 13, Fannie
Mae published Announcement SVC-2012-10, which updates its notice
of data breach and incident response policy to require servicers
to provide written notice to Fannie Mae of a data breach in
addition to any reporting to consumers or state authorities
required under applicable state law. A servicer also must
request permission to use Fannie Mae's name if it intends to
refer to Fannie Mae in any notices sent to affected borrowers or
regulatory agencies. On the same day, Fannie Mae also published
Announcement SVC-2012-11, which updates and clarifies for all
mortgages with a foreclosure sale date on or after January 1,
2012, (i) the maximum allowable foreclosure time frames for
twelve jurisdictions, (ii) compensatory fee assessments and
appeals, and (iii) the preferred method of foreclosure in
Montana and Nebraska. Here are the announcements: https://www.efanniemae.com/sf/guides/ssg/annltrs/pdf/2012/svc1210.pdf
and https://www.efanniemae.com/sf/guides/ssg/annltrs/pdf/2012/svc1211.pdf.
Freddie Mac has clarified that, with regards to non-REO
expense reimbursements, taxes incurred and paid to a taxing
authority may be reimbursed up to 12 months before the last paid
installment through the payoff date. Wire transfers are now
allowed for REO-related remittances. A time frame for sending
completed modification agreements to document custodians has
also been formalized. Homeowners impacted by the automatic stay
under bankruptcy law are to be excluded from quality right party
contact performance measurements in Servicer Success Scorecards
due to the fact that the law impedes communication with these
borrowers.
As of July 1, 2012, MERS will require all loans closed
in Mississippi to include a “physical business mailing
address” on documents such as MOM security instruments,
satisfactions, assignments, modifications, and subordinations.
The Maryland Mortgage Bankers Association has penned and
distributed a letter to the CFPB regarding the definition of a
qualified mortgage as it pertains to the pending ability to
repay rule. Stating that the definition of a QM should be
“structure[d]…as a strong legal safe harbor and not as a
rebuttable presumption,” the letter implores the CFPB to
consider protecting borrowers from poorly underwritten mortgages
and giving credit-worthy borrowers to decent mortgages equally.
Those interested in circulating the letter can find out more by
visiting http://www.mortgagebankers.org/Advocacy/MortgageActionAlliance.
Grandpoint Capital, Inc. and NCAL Bancorp have agreed to a
merger whereby the former will acquire NCAL Bancorp and
the National Bank of California, whose assets total $340.9
million, will become a wholly owned subsidiary. All outstanding
preferred NCAL Bancorp shares issued to the Department of the
Treasury will be redeemed for $10.5 million as well as current
accrued but unpaid dividends of $605,000 and any dividends
accrued through closing. Keefe, Bruyette & Woods acted as
Grandpoint Capital’s financial advisor for the transaction.
As part of its initiative to expand into being a full-service
lender, Real Estate Mortgage Network is launching its
new correspondent division and enlisting the services of Bela
Donine as Managing Director of Correspondent Lending and Melissa
Sherman as Managing Director of West Coast Operations.
Wells Fargo has saved itself $1.5 million by installing
7,000 LED signs across the country, which has cut down
electricity bills. (Go Green!) It’s also requiring Flood
Disclosures for all applications received on and after April 9,
2012, including properties that have maximum coverage and are
not presently in a flood zone. This is due to the fact that the
consumer would be able to decrease their coverage to an
unacceptably low level at a later date and the fact that flood
zones can change, respectively. The Notice of Special Flood
Hazards is required one day before signing at the minimum. All
sellers must comply with Wells’ flood protocol regardless of any
federal requirements as dictated by their licensing or
regulator.
On Friday our 10-yr t-note closed at 1.66%, roughly where it
resided much of last week. After a downward/worsening move
occurred early after the news hit of some stability in Europe,
the markets tended to improve during the day. But that was then
– what about today? We’re nearly unchanged, but that doesn’t
mean we don’t have a lot of potential volatility this week,
including the mid-week holiday which could make Thursday and
Friday a little iffy. One trader noted, “This week promises to
be somewhat illiquid and as a result will likely create decent
trading opportunities for those that wait for the right levels
to initiate trades. 1.59% remains resistance on 10s, while 1.70%
represents support.”
For
scheduled, non-European news we have the ISM Index and
Construction Spending today. Tomorrow is Factory Orders.
Thursday is Challenger Job Cuts, the ADP employment numbers,
Initial Jobless Claims, and ISM Services. Friday is the whole
spate of unemployment data. With all that we find the 10-yr
at 1.65% and agency MBS prices nearly unchanged.
Very
punny, part 1 of 2:
Ratio
of an igloo's circumference to its diameter Eskimo Pi
2000 pounds of Chinese soup Won ton
1 millionth of a mouthwash 1 microscope
Time between slipping on a peel and smacking the pavement 1
bananosecond
Weight an evangelist carries with God 1 billigram
Time it takes to sail 220 yards at 1 nautical mile per hour Knotfurlong
16.5 feet in the Twilight Zone 1 Rod Serling
Half of a large intestine 1 semicolon
1,000,000 aches 1 megahurtz
Basic unit of laryngitis 1 hoarsepower
Shortest distance between two jokes A straight line
453.6 graham crackers 1 pound cake
1 million-million microphones 1 megaphone
2 million bicycles 2 megacycles
365.25 days 1 unicycle
2000 mockingbirds 2 kilomockingbirds
If
you're interested, visit my twice-a-month blog at the STRATMOR
Group web site located at www.stratmorgroup.com.
The current blog discusses the issue of the Freddie Mac &
Bank of America buybacks, and its potential impact on the
industry. If you have both the time and inclination, make a
comment on what I have written, or on other comments so that
folks can learn what's going on out there from the other
readers.