Jul. 24, 2012: Mortgage jobs; Realtors & the CFPB; Flagstar & First Horizon diverge; a primer on fiscal versus monetary policy; Spain too big to bale?
Rob Chrisman
"Rob,
when
do you think that the CFPB will go after us Realtors?"
I am not convinced that it will, although there are plenty of
arguments why it might. But the usual inquiry I receive -
"When is the CFPB going to go after those agents who get a 5
or 6% commission?" - isn't quite valid. A standard 5-6% might be
considered high by many, but it is very transparent. And
one of the CFPB's objectives is to stop non-transparent,
misleading transactions. (And Realtors aren't involved in a
refinance, so the sheer number of transactions is lower.) What
the CFPB may concentrate on are agreements outside of the
usual paperwork, or Realtors encouraging a buyer to look at a
more expensive house, which is obviously very similar to any
sales person's pitch whether it be cars, suits, sheets,
vacations...the list goes on. Which is why the CFPB had better
tread carefully - it is a dangerous and slippery slope to
regulate, homogenize, and limit all sales-related compensation
structures.
Continuing
this discussion, I’ve heard from a couple sources that it was
said that during the recent CFPB SBREFA panel on the Mortgage
Originator Compensation Rule Proposal two items of interest
emerged. The first involved the proposal of a flat fee. The
CFPB clearly stated to an Affiliated Business that in an
affiliated transaction the Realtor's compensation must be
included in the Flat Fee. Second, supposedly one of the panel
members asked if it was CFPB's intention to put every
individual paid on basis point commission on a flat fee. CFPB
seemingly ignored the question. (I hope not.) In many folks’
opinions, at this point it is difficult to tell if the CFPB's
opinions/direction is anti-small business, anti-large
business, or neither and it just seems that way. Do I believe
Realtors are a target? Yes, but first the CFPB will first
focus on all the brokers and small bankers – and as we know
many Realtors and loan officers are “small businesses.”
Comstock
Mortgage, headquartered in Sacramento CA, is statistically a
small business but is expanding. Comstock is currently
seeking experienced Retail Branch Managers, Senior
Processors and Senior Underwriters to support its growth
to $1 Billion in fundings. The lender is locally owned (by
originators) and growing rapidly in Northern California. For
more information on the company visit www.comstockmortgage.com
and interested parties should send their resume in confidence
to jobs@comstockmortgage.com.
In
addition, Stearns Lending is searching for motivated and
ambitious candidates for the following positions in all
their Regional Operations Centers: Conventional &
Government Underwriters, Funders, Account Managers,
Registration, and RESPA Specialists. Their centers are
located in Orange County, CA, Campbell, CA, Concord, CA, Santa
Rosa, CA Portland, OR, Salt Lake City, UT, Phoenix, AZ,
Denver, CO, Chicago, IL, Warwick, RI, Tampa, FL. (The Campbell
Regional Center is also looking for an Operations
Manager.) Stearns was founded in 1989 and is the 5th largest
privately held lender nationwide, priding itself on product,
price, and service as its growth continues. Please forward
your resume to Yvonne Ketchum at yketchum@stearns.com.
There
are
a couple company-specific news items that indicate the state
of flux in which we find ourselves. Recently shares of Flagstar
Bancorp rose as much as 12% after it posted its first
profit in nearly four years. Forget for the moment that
its shares were at $107/share in late 2007 and now they are
down to around $1/share – the company showed a profit! (The
bank's bad loan provisions halved to $58.4 million.) But over
at First Horizon National Corporation, it reported a 2nd
quarter loss (following five consecutive profitable quarters)
due to an increase in reserves for GSE mortgage
repurchases. Besides the increased provisions for
mortgage buybacks, the company also made litigation-related
accruals. Also, provision for loan losses reported an increase
to $15 million from $8 million reported in the prior quarter
and $1 million reported in the year-ago quarter.
Out
in the west, there are two news stories related to
foreclosures that are worth noting. First, the number of
California homes entering foreclosure is at five-year low.
Attribute it to whatever reason you like (backlog, legal
hassles, ensuring a thorough process, fewer borrowers in
trouble, etc.), CA’s NOD’s in the second quarter fell 2.9%
from the first quarter and 3.6% from a year earlier. DataQuick
reported that the number of California homes entering the
foreclosure process slipped to the lowest level since
mid-2007. The number of homes lost to foreclosure plummeted.
Still, the overall numbers are sizeable: 54,615 notices of
default were filed on California homes and condominiums in the
second quarter.
To
California’s north, last week the Oregon Court of Appeals
struck a blow to the mortgage industry by ruling that the
document-registry system (MERS) could not be used to
skirt state recording law in out-of-court foreclosures. In a
decision with implications beyond the MERS, the state's
second-highest court also held that a lender must ensure a
complete ownership history of the mortgage is filed in county
records before it can foreclose outside a courtroom. MERS has
racked up an impressive series of court victories, including
many in Oregon, and this will be appealed. But this court
found that the Oregon Trust Deed Act requires the party that
receives loan payments to publicly record all changes in
mortgage ownership before starting a so-called non-judicial
foreclosure. MERS does not take loan payments and does not
qualify as a "beneficiary" of a trust deed, so the digital
registry cannot be used to avoid the recording requirement,
the court ruled. Some banks already have decided to file some
foreclosures in court (judicial foreclosure) that lenders say
will take longer and cost more. For example, in Hawaii last
year when a new law requiring judicial foreclosures went into
effect, foreclosure activity dropped by more than half.
Servicers are well aware that the average time to complete a
foreclosure grew from 278 days in the second quarter of 2011
to 505 days a year later.
Greece,
and much of Europe, has been relatively quiet for several
weeks, but problems have reared up again. (They never went
away.) Things once again are changing daily, but the German
vice chancellor said Greece will miss their budget targets,
and the flow of bailout funds will stop. That means
insolvency. Does it mean Greece will exit? Spain isn't any
better either – their yields, reflecting risk, are hitting new
highs. Interestingly, Spain’s 5-yr yield is trading above its
10-yr yield!
In
this country, the “fiscal cliff” is starting to take hold in
trader's/corporate's mindset, and QE3 is probably on its way.
GDP and inflation are on a one-way street lower – could
our rates be heading lower? There sure isn’t much reason
for them to go higher. At the June 20 post-FOMC press
conference, Ben Bernanke said “Monetary policy isn’t going to
solve our problems.” This quote says a lot. If Congress can’t
get fiscal policy in order, the U.S. economy will just
continue with a "slow recovery."
But
what
is the difference between fiscal and monetary policy? Fiscal
policy
includes the government's range of taxation and expenditure
options by which it can affect the course of a nation's
economy. Fiscal policy tools include tax cuts and spending
increases. The legislative and executive branches of
government control fiscal policy. Governments often use fiscal
policy tools in times of a weak economy. In times of an
economic recession or depression, government policymakers hope
that fiscal policy will provide a short-term economic stimulus
that leads to long-term growth. Government spending, along
with consumer spending and investment by firms, is an element
in determining a nation's gross domestic product, or GDP. Many
economists contend that government fiscal policy has a
multiplier effect. As government increases spending or reduces
the amount of taxes people pay, it increases the overall
demand for goods and services in the economy. But fiscal
policy does have a downside: higher government spending often
leads to higher interest rates, which reduces investment and
overall demand for goods and services by making it more
expensive to borrow money, commonly referred to as the
“crowding out” effect.
Monetary
policy
refers to the range of policy instruments by which a
government tries to manage the nation's money supply. (I
remember when money supply figures were released every
Thursday afternoon, and moved the markets.) Monetary policy's
goals include protecting the purchasing power of money by
acting to control inflation. The Federal Reserve has control
over monetary policy. Monetary policy instruments include the
buying and selling of government bonds (known as open market
operations), changing the proportion of reserves that banks
are required to hold against deposits, and changing the
interest rates that central banks charge member banks for
loans. All monetary policy instruments can expand or contract
the money supply, and all monetary policy tools strive to
protect the value of money and prevent inflation. Expansionary
monetary policy, such as buying government bonds from the
public, reducing banks' reserve requirements or cutting key
interest rates expand the money supply by putting more money
into circulation or increasing the percentage of deposits that
banks are able to lend. Central banks will use expansionary
monetary policy in times when the economy is in a recession.
But as we know, the pace of economic growth has been
frustratingly slow and the recovery has lost momentum in
recent months. And we need jobs and housing, housing and jobs.
It is nice to have low rates, but if a borrower’s job and
income are questionable, they won’t qualify regardless of a
3.5% mortgage. The economy is weighed down by the ongoing
European sovereign debt crisis and fiscal tightening in our
own country. In these circumstances, it is essential that the
Federal Reserve provide sufficient monetary accommodation to
keep our economy moving towards the central bank’s maximum
employment and price stability mandates. Check it out: http://www.frbsf.org/publications/economics/letter/2012/el2012-22.html.
Sticking
with the economy, Monday was a bit of a snoozer of a day,
although we saw a few intra-day price changes from lenders.
There was no data in the U.S. of note, so aside from watching
stocks sell off there wasn’t much exciting. Spain is in big
trouble as many regions within the country are now asking an
already broke government for bailout funds. The only thing
good about Spain is that it is not as bad off as Greece (yet)!
Both countries may be considered “too big to bail.” (Actually
“bale”.)
As
our 10-yr closed at 1.44%, agency mortgage-backed securities
improved: 30-yr 3%’s (containing 3.25-3.625% home loans) are
above 104 (4 point premium) and 30-yr 2.5% securities are
above 101! For mortgages, “more buyers than sellers” is the
name of the game.
Today
could be more of the same, as there is no economic news here
to move rates. We do, however, have the May FHFA house price
index (seen +0.5 vs. +0.8 last), and a $35 billion 2-yr note
auction. Keeping those eyes on Europe, in the early going
the 10-yr is unchanged at 1.44% as are MBS prices.
RETIRE WHERE? We have choices – part 2 of 5:
You can retire to California where...
1. You make over $250,000 and you still can't afford to buy a
house.
2. The fastest part of your commute is going down your
driveway.
3. You know how to eat an artichoke.
4. You drive your leased Mercedes to your neighborhood block
party.
5. When someone asks you how far something is, you tell them
how long it will take to get there rather than how many miles
away it is.
6. The 4 seasons are: Fire, Flood, Mud, and Drought.
If
you're interested, visit my twice-a-month blog at the STRATMOR
Group web site located at www.stratmorgroup.com.
The current blog discusses the FinCen, SAR’s, and the impact
on mortgage lenders. If you have both the time and
inclination, make a comment on what I have written, or on
other comments so that folks can learn what's going on out
there from the other readers.