Aug. 2, 2012: LOS primer; VA loan changes coming? Appraisers to have comp set in stone? San Bernardino bankrupt
Rob Chrisman
That
commercial sector is rockin' and rollin', up 25% for the 2nd
quarter from a year ago. Granted, most of that was due to
increases in originations for retail and hotel properties. The
MBA noted that, "The increase included a 56% increase in the
dollar volume of loans for retail properties, a 22% increase
for hotel properties, a 19% increase for multifamily
properties, a 15% increase for office properties, an 11%
increase in health care property loans. These gains offset a
5% decrease in industrial property loans." Here you go: http://www.mbaa.org/NewsandMedia/PressCenter/81459.htm.
Remember
New Century? Formed in 1995 from some folks from Option One,
it fell into bankruptcy during the first half of 2007. Reuters
reported that the Public Employees' Retirement System of
Mississippi led a group of investors in a lawsuit against
Goldman Sachs Group in which they claimed they were misled by
the bank into purchasing mortgage securities from New Century
Financial, which went bankrupt in 2007. Goldman has agreed to
settle the suit by paying $20 million to $21.3 million to
investors, depending on whether a Dutch pension fund decides
to join the class action suit. Goldman will pay another $5.3
million in legal fees and expenses: http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/07/31/us-goldman-mortgage-settlement-idUSBRE86U1PA20120731.
Whether
it is a yellow pad, or a highly complex vendor-generated
program, every originator needs a way to track his or her
pipeline. But LOS (Loan Origination Software) is a tricky
subject. “Rob, I’ve used excel in the past to compare loan
options, our LOS doesn’t really do a very good job of selling
the client on their best solution. Our company recently said
that we can’t use tools that we create ourselves, and they
want to approve any client facing materials. Why is that?
What are your thoughts on presenting loan options to clients?”
I
am going to preface this by saying that I am not an expert in
LOS, but I know how it fits in with the industry. Lenders are
responsible for the actions of their loan officers, and
logical or mathematical mistakes could put your company at
risk. Lenders are learning from the financial planning
industry, and in that industry the company provides the
platform or solution that the financial advisor uses for asset
management. Having loan officers using home grown solutions
creates a real headache if a future client presentation needs
to be reviewed by a compliance officer in an audit, or legal
issue. In other words I think you’ll see in the future that
most companies provide the liability management tools for
their loan officers, just like the big financial planning
firms have for years. There’s too much risk to you and your
company using home grown solutions.
A
LOS conversion is one of the most important projects a
mortgage company can undertake. The advent of the hosted
platforms, where a low initial investment can get a client
onto their “dream” software in a very short time, can lead to
flawed implementations and ongoing reconfiguration efforts.
There is a low barrier of entry for vendors offering new
systems, and “in the old days” mortgage companies only had to
consider the cost of the software (licensing and maintenance
costs are not cheap), cost of the hardware (upgrading software
also meant upgrading servers which required pouring money into
a diminishing asset), and the cost of the implementation (IT
guys’ time isn’t cheap). A mid-sized lender could easily spend
9-12 months on implementations with a minimum investment of
$500k.
Today,
things are different. Bankers can get access to excellent
software through a hosted platform for a minimal
investment. But it still takes time, and experts will tell you
the more time the better. It would be a mistake to think that
a low cost, hosted platform, with a pay as you go formula
leads to a successful implementation. Hosted or
non-hosted implementations both require a detailed project
plan and manager to lead all efforts. Until recently
this has been the IT director, but with the hosted platform,
their value is somewhat minimized to simply obtaining a strong
internet connection and installing the software to
desktops. These implementations now require a “mortgage mind”
who also understands technology so it can be customized to
match the proper workflow. You don’t want to implement
something that the LO’s can’t or won’t use, or rush through
it, trying to meet that 90-day deadline, and miss out learning
(and teaching the LO’s) about the “bells and whistles” a
system offers. It seems that a lot of functionality goes
unnoticed or under-utilized as nobody ever took the time to
build a holistic workflow within the LOS from the start. The
lack of a true implementation manager who "gets it" leads to
inefficient and manual processes, taken from the old LOS, and
inserted into the new.
It
seems
that most originators are looking at new LOS, because
they’ve outgrown or are unhappy with it, or have just added
new LOS.
(Take a poll some time with a bunch of lenders in the room.)
The LOS should be a game changer for every firm, allowing for
a streamlined, user-friendly origination process. It should
provide the engine needed to support current and future
volume, eliminate manual processes through automation,
eliminate the need for tracking spreadsheets, and allow
enforcement of corporate policies in today’s
compliance/regulatory environment.
How
long does this take? Banks and other lenders need to invest in
a workflow analysis, a thorough decision making process, a
strong testing plan for the new LOS and an in-depth migration
plan. If you think you can roll one out successfully, given
the planning and analysis, in a month or two, it is highly
unlikely. Really breaking down and understanding underwriting
and processing is 30 days alone, secondary and post-closing is
another 30, and there's still sales, QC, accounting, testing,
training, etc.
There
are dozens of systems out there, and I am not going to list
every one. But one of the more popular solutions that is
gaining a lot of traction in the industry is the Borrow
Smart sales presentation system at Mortgage Success Source. As
I mentioned, I am no expert, but I’ve seen it myself, and it’s
designed for the loan officer to sell more while offering
greater protection to the company. Overall, it could increase
LO conversion rates, and that’s a win/win for you and your
company. Contact Bill Bodnar, bbodnar@mssllc.com for
a demo. Or contact Len Tichy at STRATMOR – he makes it his job
to keep up on these things: len.tichy@stratmorgroup.com.
On
to something almost as much fun, like bankruptcies. Ally
Financial swung to a loss (almost $900 million) in the
second quarter as its mortgage unit Residential Capital limped
through bankruptcy. Ally took a $1.2 billion charge from
placing ResCap into bankruptcy in May, and reports indicate
that Berkshire Hathaway replaced Ally as the stalking horse
bidder on the failed mortgage unit's loan portfolio. ResCap
aside, the Ally mortgage unit originated $5.9 billion in
residential mortgages during the quarter versus $12.3
billion in last year’s quarter – 82% of that was refinances.
And for something near and dear to every CEO’s heart, Ally
holds $124 million in reserves for repurchases and has roughly
$82 million in buyback claims outstanding as of June 30.
Along
the bankruptcy lines, the Southern California city of San
Bernardino (pop. 200,000) declared Chapter 9 bankruptcy
yesterday, joining Stockton (pop. 300,000) and Mammoth Lakes
(pop. 8,000). They, like other places in the U.S., have
been hit by the slow economy and by huge pension and
government service obligations. On the other side of the
income statement, property tax revenues have also declined due
to dropping values. (Mammoth Lakes sought protection July 2
after a property developer won a $43 million court judgment
against the resort town. Experts say this filing should not be
lumped in with the other two California municipal bankruptcies
since it was an unusual circumstance.) The County of San
Bernardino, along with the cities of Fontana and Ontario, has
been in the news lately due to considering using eminent
domain as a way to seize non-agency mortgages out of pools –
something that would set a dangerous precedent for the
securitization business.
Taxes
are a problem for everyone. "I've got the IRS auditing my
company right now (I know, how pleasant). In the state of
Virginia business performed at ANY location mandates a
license, so I reimburse our employees for their home office
expenses to the tune of $1500 per month, because they
regularly conduct business at home. This was determined to be
the cost per square foot if we opened our own office nearby.
The IRS is claiming that we can't deduct for home office
reimbursement even if it is mandated by the state. They say
that we should only be allowed to reimburse them for the
license fee of $150. The auditor is saying, ‘No documentation
was provided substantiating that payment to employees for a
home office is a common or customary expense of the mortgage
industry’. So the question is: Anyone else have experience
with paying for home offices or dealing with the IRS over
this issue? Or any blog I can turn to for others in
this scenario?” Write to Robert Lee at rlee@1nmc.com.
After
much-ado-about-nothing, the Federal Open Market Committee did
not take any easing action at its current meeting. The
committee made some small changes to its statement that are
consistent with a dovish bias yet remaining in watch-and-wait
mode, and indicated they will "closely monitor incoming
information" and "will provide accommodation as needed." We
have nearly a month and a half until the next meeting on
September 13, and plenty of economists think things may weaken
further before that, which will prompt more Fed action. But do
more asset & MBS purchases really spur the jobs market or
the economy?
Now
everyone can wait until tomorrow’s jobs data, with Non-farm
Payroll expected to come in around +100k. Unfortunately for
the current administration and the economy, +100k does not
help reduce unemployment. And looking at Europe, the suspense
will finally “end” today when ECB president Mario Draghi sits
down before reporters and outlines a plan to save Europe. And
once again the markets and the media have elevated a singular
European event, billing it as a major “make-or-break” moment
for the Continent. I’ll call B.S. – excuse the language - in
reality, this is simply the latest summit/meeting of many
going back years at which officials are (slowly) shifting the
fundamentals of the EMU and it won’t be the last.
This
morning’s Initial Jobless Claims came in at 365k versus
estimates of 370k, below the 400k level. Yesterday’s 10-yr
Treasury note went out at 1.53%, and in the early going
we’re a shade better with the 10-yr down to 1.50%.
I was visiting my son and daughter-in-law last night when I
asked if I could borrow a newspaper.
"This is the 21st century, old man," he said. "We don't waste
money on newspapers. Here, you can borrow my iPod."
I can tell you, that fly never knew what hit it...