Aug. 3, 2012: What is the fastest growing commercial sector? MI news, good & bad, runs rampant; BofA & Fannie grapple over $10 billion
Rob Chrisman
What
say we end the week with something light, but near and dear to
my heart: stuff. Whether it is my grandfather's army
uniform from the Spanish American war, my high school
oceanography notes, my bottle cap collection, or a license
plate I found by the side of the road in St. Thomas in 1980,
I've kept it. And it is all really valuable, right? (Snort.)
But there are lots of us out there, and the SSA is here to
help! You've never heard of the Self Storage Association?
10% of the households in the U.S. store stuff somewhere in a
facility – I love seeing $50,000 cars parked in driveways
because they won’t fit in the garage. There are roughly 17,000
Starbucks worldwide, and 33,000 McDonalds worldwide - about
equal to the number of public storage facilities just in the
US! The self-storage industry in the United States has a
collective $20+ billion in annual revenues (2010). The
industry has been the fastest growing segment of the
commercial real estate industry over the last 30 years:
http://www.selfstorage.org/ssa/Content/NavigationMenu/AboutSSA/FactSheet/default.htm.
Well,
this was bound to happen. I was contacted by a non-bank
lender, doing less than $50 million per month, who is about
to be audited by the CFPB. It reminded me of something
this commentary has written about several times: if you think
you're not going to be audited by the CFPB, you're most likely
incorrect. Management asked me if I knew of anyone they
could speak with, who has been through this, or is going
through a CFPB audit, on an informal basis about advice. So if
that description fits, and you don't mind sharing information,
let me know and I'll put you in touch. Or, if you'd like me to
publish some anonymous comments in the commentary about what
it was like, shoot me an e-mail. (I wish I had the
technological savvy to set up an "Audited by the CFPB" user's
group.)
Of
course, while all this auditing is going on, and resources are
dedicated to buybacks (see paragraph below), many lenders are
stretched to the limit. Volume capacity remains a concern
with lenders. While most lenders welcome loan
origination volume, the recent activity that has been ongoing
has caused some operational and fulfillment
challenges. Remember when folks offered 10-day locks? I
haven’t seen that for a while. On average, most lenders
are seeing the majority of locks at 60 days in order to
satisfy back office support (processing, underwriting,
appraisal orders, and scheduled closings). Although week over
week origination activity is being reported by some lenders to
be flat or down 5%-10%, mortgage pipelines are still remaining
at all-time highs to manage.
In
speaking with Capital Markets folks, I love hearing stories
about how they succeeded in defeating buyback requests.
Negotiating skills are critical, as is a sound knowledge of
loan processing and underwriting – especially when you’re
dealing with $10 billion in buybacks. So it even
applies to the big guys, like Bank of America and FannieMae: http://in.reuters.com/article/2012/08/02/bankofamerica-fannie-idINL2E8J2F4120120802
Private mortgage insurance is alive and well. It's been
more than three years since mortgage insurance companies have
insured as much in volume as they did in June. It's been even
longer since policies in force increased. Mortgage insurers
issued 34,169 policies for $9.459 billion during June. The
last time dollar volume was that strong was in March 2009,
when $9.859 billion in policies were written. June's total
reflected activity at Mortgage Insurance Companies of America
(MICA) members Genworth, MGIC, and Radian Guaranty. But the
2009 numbers additionally reflected volume from former MICA
members PMI, RMIC, and United Guaranty. (Also current
noticeably absent from MICA is Essent.) A year earlier, when
data for PMI and Republic was still included, 24,161 policies
were written for $4.769 billion. From Jan. 1 through July 31,
mortgage insurers wrote 177,038 policies for $42.329 billion.
But
all is not so rosy in the biz. MGIC Investment Corp.'s
disclosure about a disagreement between its insurance
regulator in Wisconsin and Freddie Mac (FHLMC) over how it
uses capital sent its share price plummeting into possible
de-listing status at the NYSE. Yesterday MGIC reported a $277
million second-quarter loss, down further from the $162
million loss suffered a year earlier. “Risk factors” are an
important part of every MI company’s reporting these days, and
one of the risk factors involved MGIC Indemnity Corp., which
was approved by Freddie Mac in January to conduct business in
states where MGIC fell below required capital and couldn't
obtain a waiver. Conditions of the agreement include a
20-to-one capital ratio for MGIC Indemnity. Industry followers
know the status with MGIC, Freddie, the state of Wisconsin’s
Office of the Commissioner of Insurance, and the order that
waives capital requirements until Dec. 31, 2013, but for more
information you can read it at: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-08-02/mgic-plunges-as-mortage-insurer-s-quarterly-loss-widens.html?cmpidyhoo.
Conversely,
AIG’s UG (United Guaranty) "nearly quadrupled its operating
income to $43 million in the quarter, as new
delinquencies fell 17 percent. UGC, once seen as a peripheral
asset, has become a core part of AIG's business as competitors
stumbled and it gained market share.” Insiders wonder about
AIG (owned 61% by the U.S. Government) and paying back TARP
money, but in the meantime: http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/08/02/us-aig-results-idUSBRE8711KM20120802.
Lastly,
a story out of the Richmond Times-Dispatch notes that "Genworth
Financial's acting chief executive officer said a
spinoff or sale of its struggling U.S. mortgage insurance
business may not be viable at this time. Comments made
Wednesday by Martin P. Klein, the interim CEO of the Henrico
County-based insurer, drove shares down 11% in one day. Klein
said that 'delinking' the mortgage insurance business from the
company 'may not necessarily be the most cost effective or
most beneficial option for investors or bondholders.' He said
a sale or spinoff may not be viable at this time 'due to
potential capital required to execute the transaction.' The
company's U.S. mortgage insurance business has suffered
repeated quarterly losses because of the housing market
downturn. In June, hedge fund Highfields Capital
Management LP increased its investment in Genworth and
said it would discuss options for the mortgage insurance
operations that could include a sale or spinoff. In an
interview, Klein noted that the mortgage insurance business
has seen narrowing losses and is expected to return to a
profit this year. The unit posted a loss of $25 million in the
second quarter compared with a loss of $255 million in the
same period in 2011. The company said the number of new
delinquencies declined."
Let’s
take a quick look at some training, conferences, and other
news items from around the biz.
Lenders
One,
the nation’s largest mortgage cooperative, will be holding
their bi-annual conference Aug 5th-8th in Chicago,
IL. 500 of the top mortgage executives in the industry will
do extensive networking, education and best practice sharing
among industry leaders including FNMA, HUD and CFPB. For
information regarding membership in Lenders One visit its
website at www.lendersone.com.
Out
in Northern California there are three complimentary training
sessions of analyzing income for the self-employed borrower
coming up, sponsored by Kinecta Federal Credit Union and
Radian Guaranty. They’re Wednesday, Aug 15 from 8:30AM-12PM in
San Ramon and in San Rafael from 1:30-5PM, and again on
Thursday, Aug 16, from 8:30AM-12PM in Cupertino. For more
information, contact Rickey Juarez at rjuarez@kinecta.org.
The
Northeast Regional Conference of Mortgage Bankers is
slated to include a panel on the proposed amendments to
Pennsylvania’s Mortgage Licensing Act and New Jersey’s
Residential Mortgage Lending Act. The panel will discuss how
Pennsylvanian regulation is affected by HUD’s SAFE Act Rule,
which would change the circumstances under which a mortgage
originator’s license would be necessary, as well as proposed
clarification regarding a Pennsylvania mortgage banker’s net
worth. The discussion will also cover the issues with fees
and charges as dictated by New Jersey’s RMLA, with special
attention given to the definition of discount points. The
conference will be held from October 9-11, and interested
parties may register at http://events.r20.constantcontact.com/register/event?oeidka07e5sw88yy62433baf&llrngb5z8dab.
There’s
nothing like Texas in August, and the FHA is offering
training in Hurst. One session is on FHA Updates. “This
free live half-day classroom training (not a webinar) will
provide clarification to current hot topics and frequently
asked questions (FAQs) in today's FHA lending environment.
Covered topics will include: Credit Scenarios, Occupancy,
Real-Estate Owned Properties (REO) and Refinance transactions
as well as most recent Mortgagee Letters. Class size is
limited, first come, first served.” A second session is on
Home Equity Conversion Mortgages (HECM) Training. “Help your
borrower’s use their home equity to work for them. This FREE
live half-day classroom training (not a webinar) will provide
an overview and updates to the HECM process to include HECM
purchase transactions and refinances. Anyone in the lending
and housing industry seeking to better understand the HECM
process could benefit from this FREE training.” HUD offers a lot of
training: http://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/HUD?src/program_offices/housing/sfh/events/events.
There
are several Texas Mortgage Bankers Association (TMBA)
events approaching. The Southern States Servicing Conference
takes place on September 19 & 20 at the Gaylord Texan
Resort in Grapevine, Texas. The registration deadline is
August 17. Also, on November 12 & 13, the 62nd Annual
Education Seminar Marketplace takes place in Sugar Land, Texas
at the Marriot Town Square. For more information and
registration, check out http://www.texasmba.org/calendar.asp.
And
I am looking forward to stopping by at the Mortgage
Bankers Association of the Carolinas yearly conference
from September 15-17 at Hilton Head. “One Voice - One Purpose”
is the theme, and one can find out more information by
clicking through some links at http://www.mbac.org/event_detail.php?id2.
Yesterday
we started off the day in the U.S. with the ECB news/news
conference, with Draghi began the conference speaking with
strong rhetoric saying “high yields are unacceptable and the
Euro is irreversible.” The immediate reaction was a selloff,
however as the conference wore on it began apparent that no
specifics had been determined and nothing new would be
implemented. No real surprise there. So aside from a little
intra-day volatility, which doesn’t help hedging pipelines,
rates didn’t really do much. Back to the Olympics!
But
does any of that matter now? Non-Farm Payroll, expected at
+100k, came out at +163k for July and the Unemployment Rate
came in at 8.3% versus June’s 8.2%. (Prior month’s revisions
knocked 6k jobs off the numbers.) Much of the Payroll change
was due to private sector jobs, up over 170k, although it was
fairly broad-based. Is the economy really stronger?
Perhaps – equities are improving. Last Friday the 10-yr closed
at 1.55%, yesterday we closed it at 1.48%, and this morning in
the early going we’re around 1.53%. In other words, not a
lot of change to rates – look for MBS prices to be
down/worse between .125-.250.
The Dreaded Call
My boss phoned me yesterday, he said, "Is everything okay at
the office?"
I said, "Yes, it's all under control. It's been a very busy
day, I haven't stopped."
"Can you do me a favor?" he asked.
I said, "Of course, what is it?"
"Speed it up a little, I'm in the foursome behind you."
If
you're interested, visit my twice-a-month blog at the STRATMOR
Group web site located at www.stratmorgroup.com.
The current blog discusses the FinCen, SAR’s, and the impact
on mortgage lenders. If you have both the time and
inclination, make a comment on what I have written, or on
other comments so that folks can learn what's going on out
there from the other readers.