Aug. 22, 2012: Fannie & Freddie short sale change; LO-Realtor comments; specified pool primer - how to pick up an extra point or two
Rob Chrisman
This
is a frightening statistic, probably one of the most worrisome
in recent years: 25% of mortgage bankers and Realtors in the
country are on medication for mental illness. That is scary –
it means that 75% are running around untreated.
Statistics
can be useful, sometimes not. On the “useful” side, the
MBA will release its weekly mortgage applications index for
the prior week. But how many of those retail applications
actually close? It turns out that the MBA informally
polls its members regularly on this question. Over the past 12
months, about 70% of purchase apps and 60% of refi apps pull
through. The purchase number has been steady, but the refi
number is up from about 50% 2 years ago. But loan origination
software vendor Ellie Mae, which processes over two
million applications per year (around 20% of all American
originations) reports that of a sampling of 33% of those
originations, it was found that, from June to July, the
overall percentage of applications that closed dropped from
46.2 to 45.8%. Not a big deal, but something to note
nonetheless. The closing rate of purchase loans, however, rose
for the third consecutive month to 58.7%, which suggests that
more borrowers are in a position to buy property.
Freddie and Fannie (and the FHFA, of course) announced
short sale changes scheduled for later this year.
Starting November 1, measures will be put in place to make
short sales of underwater homes easier for homeowners,
including extending help to people who have financial
difficulties but haven't missed mortgage payments. F&F are
revising their short sale guidelines and delegating authority
to their mortgage servicers to approve short sales as of
November 1. The new procedures are part of the Servicing
Alignment Initiative which the Federal Housing Finance Agency
has directed the GSEs to develop. It is hoped that the
streamlined program rules will enable lenders and servicers to
quickly and easily qualify borrowers, who do not have to be
delinquent on their mortgages, to qualify for short sales. As
a further step to facilitate speedy sales, both of the GSEs
have authorized a payment of up to $6,000 to incentivize
second lien holders to allow the short sales to proceed. (Here
is Freddie’s bulletin, for example: http://www.freddiemac.com/sell/guide/bulletins/pdf/bll1216.pdf.)
Every
lender and Realtor out there knows that short sales can drag
on for months, although they are not as difficult or lengthy
as they were in previous years. This is in part due to a short
sale needing both the holders of first and second mortgages,
such as home-equity loans if they exist, must sign off on the
deal because they are accepting less than the outstanding
mortgage balance. Short sales typically sell for a 10%
discount to ordinary homes, compared with a 30% discount for
foreclosures, said Sam Khater of CoreLogic Inc. One part of
the plan is for Fannie and Freddie to place a $6,000 cap (will
it be enough?) on the amount of money holders of second
mortgages can receive when the sale is completed, as a way to
prevent the mortgage holders from haggling over their slice of
the home-sale proceeds. Those second-lien holders would still
be able to reject the sales if they saw fit.
Let’s
take a quick look at some related numbers. About 4.6 million
borrowers with loans backed by Fannie or Freddie are
underwater, with 80% of those homeowners having missed no
mortgage payments. The biggest holders of second mortgages in
the U.S. are Bank of America, Wells Fargo, JPMorgan Chase, and
Citigroup. Short sales have been growing as a percentage of
home sales. They made up 8.8% of home sales in May, up from
7.6% a year earlier and 6.5% in 2010, according to CoreLogic
Inc.
“The
National Association of Realtors applauds the Federal Housing
Finance Agency for working with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to
issue new guidelines that expand eligibility criteria and
streamline the short sale process. The new guidelines would
offer a more streamlined short sale approach for homeowners
most in need, as well as enable lenders to quickly and easily
qualify certain homeowners for a short sale who are current on
their mortgage payments, yet suffer from specific hardships
such as job relocation, increase in housing expenses,
unemployment and disability. The FHFA guidelines will also
consolidate existing short sales programs into a single
uniform process and provide lenders and homeowners clarity on
processing a short sale when a foreclosure sale is pending.”
While
we’re on NAR, a while back the commentary discussed some LO
– Realtor issues and comparisons. Two last notes on the
topic. "Each profession has its problems and rewards.
Comparing the difficulties of each in an attempt to justify
earnings is a meaningless exercise. Each makes its
contribution to a complete transaction (don't leave out the
title companies, appraisers and all other involved vendors)
and is compensated according to what the market will allow.
Well, at least this was the way it worked until compensation
limits were imposed by the government on the mortgage industry
in an attempt to protect the poor consumer…With all of our new
disclosures including the three loan comparisons, my customers
just sigh and sign the 28 forms attendant to each application,
and they're no more informed than when they walked in the door
unless they actually read and questioned the content of some
of the documents (the most FAQ is why is the APR higher than
my interest rate?). With the regulations on this industry and
risks of financial penalties increasing by orders of magnitude
on a regular basis, it's amazing how many are willing to stay
in it. We should all quit playing the "I work harder than
you do" game and work to lessen government involvement in
our industries."
And
Martin L. from iServe writes, "I started in the Real Estate
Industry at the age of 19 and it's almost all I know; 13 years
as a producing Realtor, and the last 14 years I have been a
successful LO. The debate over who works harder is at best a
moot point. It has us watch the ball and not the powers that
swing the ball. If we are to thrive and grow and I'm on the
side looking to thrive, we must work together and become
stronger using our collective resources - spending energy
debating issues as unimportant as reality TV. Our focus and
attention need to change from fear based to abundant and
proactive thinking. So, let's join teams with Realtors,
Lenders, Title, Insurance, Escrow and build a voice that
addresses the foundation of our economy "Real Estate."
My cat Myrtle knows nothing about "specified pools."
(And she doesn't seem overly interested in CNBC or Bloomberg
Radio in the mornings when I am polishing up the day's
commentary, either.) One would suggest that much of the
origination side of the biz knows nothing about them either. A
trader's note caught my eye last week. "In specifieds the
story of the day was in Midget 3's, which saw the bid pop from
1-04 to 1-08 as there is finally deep real money sponsorship.
Midget payups are about 1-00 off their highs from Q1 and have
lagged the payup increase on all other new production
stories." Huh?
I also received this note on small loan sizes: "Since your
email about the loan amounts below $85K I have been
prospecting around to find lenders or brokers who specialize
in smaller loan amounts. All I am finding is the opposite. In
fact, it seems like a lot of lenders are downright
punitive when it comes to smaller loan amounts. Many
charge regressive add-ons that increase as the loan amount
decreases. If there is such a premium on the secondary market
for these loans why are they being charged up so heavily?
Would you say this is indeed another victim of Dodd-Frank?
Here in the lead aggregation world we see almost a third of
our inquiries from borrowers below $100K and below 80% LTV.
These are people who could be helped, but they are getting
priced out by usurious lenders who don’t think 108 on the back
and a point up front is enough. It feels like there is a
serious disconnect here! Don’t get me wrong, I know a few
lenders who can make this work, but by and large I have a better chance of
selling bovine suppositories to a lender than leads for loan
amounts below $100K." So observed Paul F. with Ybrant
Interactive Media.
So what happens to loans that aren't average loans?
What do the aggregators do with small loans, or high LTV
loans? They, and the agencies, package them and sell them in
separate pools. It turns out that investors will often pay
higher prices, 2-3 points in some cases, for loans that
will be on their books, and being serviced, for a longer
period of time. The secondary market segregates pools into
Ginnie, Fannie, or Freddie securities, and then, if an
originator or aggregator has enough volume with
certain attributes and interest rates, pools will be created
filled with those loans. Small loan amounts (less than $175k),
high LTV insured product, low FICO agency loans in some
states, 20 or 10 year maturities are usually in the highest
demand.
And some middle-market firms make an active market in
these, often sharing the pay-up with the originator. For
example, Tad Dahlke, Senior Managing Director with Banc of
Manhattan Capital and who I met with recently, wrote,
"Pay-ups continue to be on a one-way road higher, with the
strongest gains coming in 30-year conventional 3.0s and
high-LTV HARP-type paper. With the recent sell-off, payups
have changed. 30-year Fannie 3.5s went from a high price of
106.25 in late-July to 104.75 today. Weakness has been
concentrated in 30-year conventional 3.5s, partly due to
higher rates/lower prices and partly due to heavy supply in
specified pools in this coupon. Also, the 100% Refi 80-90 LTV
sector has been struggling across coupons. The spec pool
market remains fluid, and payups are likely to bounce around
some until the bond market finds a new range." If you'd like a
current pricing grid from Tad, or more information on how
specified pools work, write to him at tad@bomcapital.com.
Tuesday
– another day, another set of chatter about Europe (the same
problems and possible solutions that have been discussed for
many months, and will be for many more months). But maybe the
U.S. economy isn't doing so poorly after all. Or maybe most of
the folks who can't make their payments have already stopped
making them. Default rates for most types of consumer loans
continued to ease during July according to the
S&P/Experian Consumer Credit Default Indices released on
Tuesday. Only second mortgages increased from June levels and
those were up only marginally from .73 percent to .75
percent. First mortgage defaults were unchanged from June at
1.41 percent which is their recent low.
On
the trading side, there wasn’t much volatility. Maybe we’re
following Europe’s lead and taking August off. Sources
reported total originator selling around $2 billion, and
hedging consisted of 60% in 30-yr 3.5%. The U.S. 10-year notes
finished better by about .125 and closed with a yield of 1.80%
while MBS prices were unchanged. Today we’ll have, but not
until 1PM CST, the minutes from the July 31-August 1 FOMC
meeting are released. What investors will be focused most
particularly on is any discussion related to additional
quantitative easing, including the various policy tools
available. We also have Existing Home Sales for July due out.
In the very early going the 10-yr is nearly unchanged at
1.79%, and MBS prices are better by a shade.
Why the English Language is hard to learn:
The bandage was wound around the wound.
The farm was used to produce produce.
The dump was so full that it had to refuse more refuse.
We must polish the Polish furniture.
He could lead if he could get the lead out.
The soldier decided to desert his dessert in the desert.
Since there is no time like the present, he thought it was
time to present the present.
The bass was painted on the head of the bass drum.
When shot at, the dove dove into the bushes.
I did not object to the object.
The insurance was invalid for the invalid.
There was a row among the oarsman about how to row.
They were too close to the door to close it.
The buck does certain things when does are present.
If
you're interested, visit my twice-a-month blog at the STRATMOR
Group web site located at www.stratmorgroup.com.
The current blog discusses the CFPB’s servicing proposals, for
better or worse. If you have both the time and
inclination, make a comment on what I have written, or on
other comments so that folks can learn what's going on out
there from the other readers.