Aug. 31, 2012: Banking & HARP chatter - M&T has to pay how much as part of the Hudson deal? Upcoming training updates
Rob Chrisman
The
first observance of Labor Day is believed to have been
a parade of 10,000 workers on Sept. 5, 1882, in New York City,
organized by Peter J. McGuire, a Carpenters and Joiners Union
secretary. By 1893, more than half the states were observing
“Labor Day” on one day or another, and Congress passed a bill
to establish a federal holiday in 1894. President Grover
Cleveland signed the bill soon afterward, designating the
first Monday in September as Labor Day. Who are we
celebrating? Well, per our Census Bureau, there are about 155
million people in the U.S. who are 16 years and older who make
up the labor force. Per its records, we have about 1.1 million
cooks, 7,800 actors, 3.1 million teachers, 395k hairdressers,
33,000 telephone operators, and 12 DE underwriters.
How
about
some banking new & HARP theory before everyone heads off
for a three day weekend? First, a few days ago the FDIC
reported that commercial banks and savings institutions
insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation reported
aggregate net income of $34.5 billion in the second quarter of
2012, a $5.9 billion improvement from the $28.5 billion in
profits the industry reported in the second quarter of 2011. This
is the 12th consecutive quarter that FDIC bank earnings have
registered a year-over-year increase. Almost two-thirds
of all institutions reported improvements in their quarterly
net income from a year ago. Also, the share of institutions
reporting net losses for the quarter fell to about 11% from
nearly 16% a year earlier. Critics note that lower provisions
for loan losses and higher gains on sales of loans and other
assets accounted for most of the year-over-year improvement in
earnings.
So
did banks set aside too much in previous years to cover
losses? Probably not, although, per the FDIC Acting Chairman,
"Levels of troubled assets and troubled institutions remain
high, but they are continuing to improve…Most institutions are
profitable and are improving their profitability. All of these
trends are consistent with the moderate pace of economic
growth that has occurred over the past year." And, say what
you want about regulation and compliance, the plethora of
exams and audits may be assisting in the trend.
But
the increased costs and problems in banking, which are
normally passed on to the consumer, and U.S. monetary policy,
also influence current events. The Financial Times points out
a recent example of Hudson City Bancorp, a New
Jersey-based thrift that M&T Bank this week agreed to
buy in a $3.7bn deal. The immediate thought was that
M&T was making a big play in the jumbo market, given
Hudson’s demographic and loan makeup. Hudson City has done
well, accepted no TARP money. Hudson did, however, go awry
on interest rate risk, borrowing money from the Federal
Home Loan Bank and using it (along with deposits) to originate
mortgages and buy securities. “As mortgage rates plunged it
spurred homeowners to refinance at lower rates. But a chunk of
Hudson City’s funding was locked in at higher ones. The bank
could not originate mortgages at high enough rates to match
its funding costs nor could it reinvest the money into assets
that earned more than it was paying. Regulators did not look
favorably on the situation and the OCC required Hudson City to
ease its interest rate risk in recent years. That proved a
costly manoeuver: the borrowings carried pre-payment
penalties.” Apparently, per the Financial Times, M&T
will have to pay $15-16 billion to unwind the remaining $13
billion of loans that still have higher costs than the
current level of rates.
Which
reminds me, a week or two ago the U.S. Treasury said it
will begin selling floating-rate notes in a year or so,
as it seeks to meet investor demand. The delay is required to
give Treasury time to change systems, choose an index and work
out details.
The
stats show that banks are the driving force of the HARP. But
many companies are focused on originating HARP & HARP II
loans, and the potential of HARP 3. But how is all this
impacting investor’s perception of non-HARP pools? The
impact of the summer rally in mortgage rates is likely to be
concentrated on the newer vintage lower coupon prepayments
(non-HARP collateral) rather than HARP prepayments. Unlike the
HARP eligible pools, prepayments on the newer vintage lower
coupons (non-HARP) have not skyrocketed in spite of the fact
that mortgage rates rallied to all-time lows in Q3 of last
year. Given that mortgage rates are around 3.75% now, or
lower, what are some of the factors that are likely to
drive prepayments on the newer vintage non-HARP pools?
Locked out borrowers with high LTV’s in the newer
vintages which have few options for refinancing, and weakness
in the housing market has pushed LTVs for some low LTV
borrowers above 80%. This, as well as the “strenuous” process
of getting accurate appraisals makes it much more
expensive and complicating for these borrowers to refinance.
The
next factor investors are talking about is borrower
outreach and indifference. I hear repeated stories
about borrowers walking in of the street with a 5% rate
asking if rates are lower than that. Lenders have been
aggressive about courting HARP eligible borrowers for
refinancing’s whereas similar marketing is not being done for
non-HARP borrowers, muting reactions of non-HARP borrowers to
the ever lower mortgage rates even though the popularity of
HARP amongst borrowers continues to be high. The third factor
is mortgage origination capacity: lenders can issue
approximately $130-135bn agency MBS on a monthly basis. Some
of the excess capacity in the system may go towards closing
purchase loans, but refinancing capacity is likely to increase
further.
The
final factor is servicer concentration. Lenders like
Wells Fargo and Chase have become a more dominant part of
recent production non-HARP pools versus the seasoned pools
where Bank of America had a fairly heavy concentration
(remember Countrywide?). Both Wells and Chase have been very
focused on HARP and have seen the HARP share of their
servicing book decline significantly as these loans paid off.
As the non-HARP loans dominate their servicing book, it could
change their focus and lead to more capacity to process the
newer loans leading to higher speeds on these new issue pools.
The belief is that factors that have led to the slower
prepayments on newer vintage lower coupons are likely to stay
intact over the next couple of months. With the pickup in
HARP, the short-term capacity constraints in the system could
become even more severe in the recent rally as lenders will
have to fully underwrite a larger portion of refi
applications. However, over the medium to long-term,
prepayments on Chase and Wells serviced non-HARP pools could
go higher as these lenders dedicate more capacity and
resources to these loans.
Turning
to some agency & investor training updates...
Fannie
Mae will be offering a number of instructor-led webinars as
part of its HFI InDepth program, the first of which is a
course on interpreting DU underwriting findings.This program will be
available on a variety of dates from September 10th
through October 24th.The “Investor Reporting with Confidence: Best Practices
for Reconciling Actual Loans” and “Bank vs. Book: Reconciling
Actual Custodial Accounts” webinars will be available on
several dates throughout September and October as well.These are aimed primarily
at originators, underwriters, and servicers.For further details on
course content and scheduling, see https://www.efanniemae.com/lc/hfindepth.jsp.
To
all new Hope LoanPort users, the FHA offers a weekly training
session every Tuesday via webinar.Advanced
classes are also available for those with an interest in
learning more about user administration, reporting, and
various other processes and procedures that aren’t covered in
the basic training.Experienced
Hope LoanPort users looking for a refresher are encouraged to
attend as well.To
register, email kbailey@hopeloanportal.org
with an email address, full organization name, city and state,
and preferred class date and time.
The
FHA Denver Homeownership Venter and the Nebraska Mortgage
Association will host “A Day with FHA” on September 6th,
a full day of training that will cover refinances, REO
calculations, transactions that affect maximum LTVs, and other
topical FHA updates.Register
at http://www.regonline.com/builder/site/Default.aspx?EventID24712
and select “HUD Training Day.”Also available on the 6th is a one-day
training on FHA appraisals.The
agenda features appraisal protocol, updates to policy, and
equipping participants with the tools to determine property
eligibility.Attendees
are eligible to receive seven hours of continuing education
credits that are accepted by the State of Nebraska for
appraisal licensing requirements.Interested parties can
register at http://www.regonline.com/builder/site/Default.aspx?EventID24712.
On
September 12th and 13th, the FHA’s Santa
Ana Homeownership Center will hold several training sessions
in Phoenix, AZ.Two-day
classes on automated vs. manual underwriting, feedback
certificates and documentation, post-endorsement technical
reviews, insuring deficiencies, FHA appraisals, and niche
underwriting topics will all be available.Though the programs are
geared primarily towards underwriters, processors, and loan
officers, all are welcome.For
those who can’t make it to Phoenix, the same training will be
available in three other locations on different dates.More
information can be found at http://www.hud.gov/emarc/index.cfm?fuseactionemar.registerEvent&eventId32&updateN.
A
webinar on the FHA’s energy efficiency measures will take
place on September 13th for those interested in
knowing more about how the Energy Efficient Mortgage (EEM)
program can assist borrowers in financing energy-saving
improvements into their mortgages.Designed for loan
originators, processors, underwriters, brokers, and agents,
the training will cover the program’s features and Home Energy
Rating System reporting.See
http://www.hud.gov/emarc/index.cfm?fuseactionemar.registerEvent&eventId43&updateN
to register.
The
NeighborWorks Training Institute will be holding several
courses for housing counselors in Washington, D.C. from
December 10-14th.More
information and registration links are available at http://nw.org/network/training/upcoming/DCNTI12.asp.
The National Reverse Mortgage Lenders’ Association will be
holding its annual meeting in San Antonio, TX from October
15-17th. Aimed at financial planners, researchers, and
construction professionals as well as lenders, the program
will discuss recent product innovation and the potential
implications of the upcoming presidential election for the
reverse mortgage industry. Speeches, panel discussions,
debates, and workshops all feature on the agenda. For more
information and registration details, see http://www.nrmlaonline.org/.
Well,
enough about learnin’, and on to the markets. Yesterday’s
Initial Jobless Claims, a leading indicator on the health of
the economy, came in at 374,000, higher than the 370,000
expected – but not much. (Adding to the negative tone of the
report was a higher revision to the previous week's reading.)
With GDP ranging between 1.5-2%, it is hard to make much of
a case for higher rates here in the United States. But
consumer spending in the U.S. climbed in July for the first
time in three months, +.4% in July, and incomes were +.3%. The
UST 10-yr yield closed at 1.62%.
Early
on
we find the 10-yr at 1.64%, and MBS prices a shade worse.
Although there is no official early close in the bond markets
today, don’t look for much going on, aside from in the funding
departments of mortgage banks, this afternoon.
Thanks to Guy Schwartz at CMG for this one: "According to
Wikipedia, the term ‘Catch-22’ was coined by Joseph Heller in
his novel Catch-22. Initially this is based on the explanation
of the character Doc Daneeka as to why any pilot requesting a
psych evaluation, hoping to be found not sane enough to fly
(and thereby escape dangerous missions), would thereby
demonstrate his sanity. Last week while processing a cash-out
loan for one of our clients, we called to tell him that when
we processed the 4506 T through the IRS, it came back with no
record found. We had a copy of the tax return he gave us. We
asked him when he filed his tax return and he then said, ‘I
haven't, I was hoping to use the money from the refinance to
pay my taxes.’ Oh boy! If this is not the quintessential Catch
22 we don't know what is: without the income on that tax
return there is no loan. We should probably just cancel that
loan.”
If
you're interested, visit my twice-a-month blog at the STRATMOR
Group web site located at www.stratmorgroup.com.
The current blog discusses the new CFPB Rule combining TILA
& RESPA disclosures. If you have both the time and
inclination, make a comment on what I have written, or on
other comments so that folks can learn what's going on out
there from the other readers.