Dec. 3, 2012: Congress targets Gfee income again; MBA/STRATMOR peer group sign-ups; mortgages at Wal-Mart?
Rob Chrisman
For
this upcoming weekend's cocktail party, tape 1 hour of CNBC on
your DVR, play it back during the party, and take a shot every
time someone says, "fiscal cliff." Guaranteed fun times – and
a hangover!
What is not “fun times,” but with the potential hangover, is
the reality of the situation, and the consequences, intended
or otherwise. It was December of 2008 when the Fed cut
short term interest rates to zero. Four years ago! But
this rate environment raises many issues. A.T. writes, “I may
be missing something since I am a simple-minded Secondary guy,
but… would the bump and extension in MI for FHA push the
APR on these loans up to a level to consider them ‘High Cost
Loans’ (APR 1.5% higher than the Average Prime Rate)?
If that is truly the case, wouldn't that be up there as one of
the stupidest unintended consequences of government in action?
The prime rate is 3.25%, so 1.5% above that is 4.75%, and few
are doing 4.75% mortgages. A perpetual MI premium would
calculate into the APR much more than the current method. A
current MI premium of 125bps in perpetuity should bump the APR
calculation more than the current calculation which I believe
shows it falling off after getting down to 78% LTV. If they
bump the MI more and it never drops off, isn't there an issue
there? A file I randomly pulled from the summer with a 3.875%
rate actually had a 4.650% APR bumped up due to the MI.” Great
observation!
It
seems that Congress is once again tempted to come back to
the “mortgage well” since the House passed HR 1629, the
STEM Jobs Act of 2012. The bill amends the Immigration and
Nationality Act to make up to 55,000 visas available to
qualified immigrants with certain advanced degrees who agree
to work for at least five years for the petitioning employer
or in the United States in a STEM field. STEM is a
designation indicating advanced training in science,
technology, engineering or math. (Not mortgage banking or real
estate.) When it was sent to the House Rules Committee the
bill was altered with what is generally known as a "payfor"
which would require
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to increase their guarantee fees
to cover the cost of implementing the STEM Jobs Act. The
MBA’s Dave urged Congress to reconsider their approach of
using guarantee fees for this purpose. He said in part,
"Fannie and Freddie's guarantee fees are supposed to be used
to help offset the risk inherent in providing mortgages, and
any increases to those fees should be used for that purpose.
Dipping back into the housing piggybank to pay for unrelated
policy items on the backs of America's homebuyers sends the
wrong message at a time when the housing market is starting to
show signs of recovery."
Speaking
of
the MBA, it and the STRATMOR Group have conducted the Peer
Group Survey and Roundtable Program since 1998. This program creates a forum for
participating mortgage banking companies to review their
financial results and operating practices in relation to their
peers. This program is widely regarded not only for its
detailed benchmarking outputs by production channel, but also
for its 1.5-day roundtable meetings. The meetings allow
companies to network and share ideas and issues with peers.
Peer groupings are flexible and change over time, but include:
mid-sized independents, large independents, mid-size
bank-affiliated lenders and large bank-affiliated lenders.
For each group meeting, the MBA/STRATMOR team compiles a
detailed presentation of historical trends and analyses of the
most current data series. If you would like to participate
in the MBA/STRATMOR upcoming Spring 2013 peer group survey
(data as of December 31) or would like additional information,
please contact Marina Walsh in MBA's research and economics
division, at mwalsh@mortgagebankers.org
or Jim Cameron at STRATMOR Group at jim.cameron@stratmorgroup.com.
Moving
on to the CFPB, Paul G. observes, regarding the budget and the
CFPB, “A recent article states that the CFPB can draw on up to
10% of the Federal Budget. That claim is just plain wrong. The
CFPB's request for FY 2013 was $448 million, not $360
billion, which is what CFPB's budget would have to be in order
for it to represent 10% of the $3.6 Trillion federal budget.
$360 billion would represent half of all discretionary
spending in the budget. I realize that the CFPB is a
convenient boogeyman for many people in our industry, but in
order to have any credibility, those writing about it,
especially in industry publications, need to describe the
CFPB as accurately as possible."
And
Julian Hebron's The Basis Point points out, "Most discussion
about the fiscal cliff fails to address the most serious
structural fiscal problems. These problems are so called ‘entitlements.’
Calling these entitlements does not mean that anyone is
legally entitled to these. All that it does is relieve
Congress from budgeting for these. This has been done for the
convenience of Congress and is entirely against the best
interests of the nation. The Treasury data analyzes the money
presently in these accounts, future anticipated revenues and
future anticipated expenses. It then present values the future
shortfalls. The conclusion is that the present value of
future shortfall was in 2010, $77.9 trillion. What does
this mean? It means that if we had $77.9 trillion in these
funds, instead of essentially zero, we would be fine." (For
the full story, go to http://thebasispoint.com/
and page down once or twice to the entitlement story by Dick
Lepre.
Huh? Now the home loan industry might be competing with
Wal-Mart or PayPal? What makes them want to enter such a new,
compliance & regulatory laden industry? Perhaps it is the
returns being earned by current lenders, and potential
borrowers are interested: http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/12/03/mortgages-walmart-idUSL1E8MRC5D20121203.
So
eventually recent lender and investor updates may include news
from Costco, Wal-Mart, or PayPal, but until then we’ll take a
look at some relatively recent training, investor, and
lender updates.
There is a free webinar on Thursday, Dec. 6, at 2PM EST: “Top
LOs: How to Recruit, Train, Support & Keep Them.
Learn what to look for in hiring great salespeople, the best
recruitment methods to use, plus tips and tricks to help you
grow your staff successfully! The webinar is hosted by Guaranteed
Home Mortgage Company headquartered in New York and
licensed in 28 states. The link for sign-ups is: http://hub.am/U6W2is.
The
Mortgage Bankers Association of New Jersey will be presenting
the Annual Joint Mortgage Lending Conference on December 11th
in Monroe Township, NJ. The program will focus on the future
of CFPB regulation and will include a speech by the Acting
Deputy Associate Director of the CFPB. Register at http://www.mbanj.com/.
Fifth
Third
is now requiring all closed loan files that were received on
or after November 19th to include a standardized Tax
Information form, which should be completed and submitted with
the closed loan package in lieu of any tax information
currently being used. The new form can be accessed online.
As a reminder, Fifth Third will suspend all loans that are
missing the documentation necessary to verify the interest
rate data as required by the Home Ownership and Equity
Protection Act for higher-priced loans, including the
HOEPA/HMDA Required Information Form and a screen print of a
populated FFIEC rate spread calculator.
Fifth Third has announced that its new Age of Note and First
Payment policies will take effect for all loans that are
currently in the pipeline on or after December 3rd. The Age
of Note policy states that the loan must be purchased within
60 days of the note date and that for escrow closing states,
the closing documents must be signed within 15 calendar days
of the note date. Under the First Payment policy, loan
payments must be current as of the date of purchase. If the
loan is purchased after the first payment due date, the
correspondent seller must have collected payment from the
borrower or made disbursements from the escrow account, the
latter of which will require the seller to provide a payment
history of all pre-purchase transactions. Sellers are also
reminded that they are required to have the ability to service
loan payments.
Flagstar has updated its policy on long-term disability
income, which must be verified by a copy of the disability
policy or benefits statement from the institution paying the
benefits or, in the case of Social Security income, a copy of
the SSA’s award letter, signed federal income tax returns,
copies of the borrower’s most recent bank statements, or a
Social Security Benefit Statement. Self-employed borrowers
are also subject to updated guidance requiring two years of
their most recent tax returns.
Effective for loan applications dated November 30th and after,
Flagstar will no longer permit streamline reviews on primary
residences in condo projects in cases where the LTV/CLTV/HCLTV
exceeds 80%.
Due to the high volume of appraisal orders Mountain West
Financial has been receiving of late, its AMC Mortgage
Works will be implementing a fee increase for FHA,
conventional conforming, and conventional non-conforming
loans. Applicable fees will be increased by $50 as of
December 1st. Property types that fall outside the typical
appraisal coverage area (Unusual, Unique, Rural, Acreage,
Waterfront, and the like) will require a direct quote from
Mortgage Works and will be subject to additional fees on top
of the $50 increase.
MWF has announced that conventional loans with LTVs over 80%
may now be fully funded by gift funds provided that they meet
specific DTI, credit score, mortgage insurance, and loan
amount criteria in addition to the standard gift
requirements. If all of the additional guidelines aren’t met,
gift funds will be considered after the borrower has fulfilled
the 3% contribution minimum.
Turning to the markets, on Friday Treasuries were roughly
unchanged on the day while news flow regarding the fiscal
cliff remained light. That certainly didn't change much over
the weekend, with some light chatter out of Asia and Europe
but it seems the world can focus its attention on the
inability for politicians to compromise until faced with...who
knows? But there is a slate of economic news this week
although most of it is "2nd tier." Today we have some
forgettable ISM index, and Construction Spending. Zip
tomorrow, and then on Wednesday the ADP employment data and
Factory Orders, along with some productivity and unit labor
costs that only an economist would love. Thursday is Jobless
Claims, but then we have Friday's Unemployment Report from the
U.S. Department of Labor. The unemployment rate equals the
number of employed persons divided by the total number of
persons in the labor force which is measured from a survey of
60,000 households. Wall Street watches this report closely and
reactions tend to be dramatic, although with the Fed buying
$40-80 billion a month of MBS, can home loan rates really do
much?(Preliminary
estimates show an increase in NFP of about 85k.)
On
Friday we closed the 10-yr at 1.61%, and MBS prices hardly
different from Thursday’s levels. This morning we find the
10-yr at 1.64% and agency MBS prices worse by about .125.
I recently picked a new primary care doctor. After two visits
and exhaustive lab tests, he said I was doing “fairly well'
for my age. (I am turning sixty in two weeks. (The joke
teller, not me!))
A little concerned about that comment, I couldn't resist
asking him, “Do you think I'll live to be 80?”
He asked, “Do you smoke tobacco, or drink beer, wine or hard
liquor?”
'Oh no,” I replied. “I'm not doing drugs, either!”
Then he asked, “Do you eat rib-eye steaks and barbecued ribs?”
I said, “Not much... My former doctor said that all red meat
is very unhealthy!”
“Do you spend a lot of time in the sun, like playing golf,
boating, sailing, hiking, or bicycling?”
“No, I don't,” I said.
He asked, “Do you gamble, drive fast cars, or have lots of
sex?”
“No,” I said...
He looked at me and said, “Then, why do you even give a
‘darn’?”
If
you're interested, visit my twice-a-month blog at the STRATMOR
Group web site located at www.stratmorgroup.com.
The current blog discusses some of the considerations facing
the FHFA regarding Fannie and Freddie. If you have both the
time and inclination, make a comment on what I have written,
or on other comments so that folks can learn what's going on
out there from the other readers.